CRA Audits & Disputes
When the CRA contacts you, experience matters
Receiving correspondence from the Canada Revenue Agency can be concerning. Whether the CRA is requesting information, commencing an audit, questioning a charity’s compliance, issuing an assessment or proposing regulatory action, it is important to understand the issues and the potential consequences before responding.
Discuss your situationDrache Aptowitzer PC advises registered charities, not-for-profit organizations, individuals and other taxpayers dealing with CRA audits, compliance matters and tax disputes. We help clients understand what the CRA is asking, identify the legal and regulatory issues involved, and develop an appropriate response.
CRA Audits of Registered Charities
Registered charities operate within a specialized regulatory environment under the Income Tax Act. The CRA Charities Directorate is responsible for monitoring compliance with the requirements associated with registered charity status.
A charity may come into contact with the CRA through a request for information, a compliance-related intervention, or a formal audit. An audit does not, by itself, mean that the charity has done something wrong. It does, however, require careful attention.
The issues raised may concern a charity’s purposes, activities, governance, books and records, fundraising, receipting, expenditures, grants or other aspects of its operations.
When questions arise, it is important to consider not only the immediate request from the CRA, but whether it points to a broader compliance issue that should be addressed.
Have You Received a Letter From the CRA?
You do not need to wait until a matter becomes a formal dispute to obtain legal advice.
A charity or other taxpayer may seek our assistance after receiving:
- a request for information or documents;
- notice of a CRA audit;
- correspondence raising compliance concerns;
- an assessment or reassessment;
- notice of a penalty or sanction;
- a compliance agreement;
- a notice relating to suspension of receipting privileges;
- a proposal to revoke charitable registration; or
- another decision or communication requiring a response to the CRA.
Getting advice early can help you understand what the CRA is asking, the significance of the issues raised, the applicable deadlines, and the options available before you respond.
What Happens if the CRA Identifies a Problem?
For registered charities, CRA compliance concerns can have consequences extending beyond an ordinary tax assessment.
Depending on the circumstances and the nature of the non-compliance identified, a matter may lead to education or corrective measures, a compliance agreement, financial penalties, suspension of certain privileges or, in serious cases, revocation of charitable registration.
The appropriate response will depend on the issues identified, the charity’s particular circumstances, and the stage of the CRA process.
Where concerns can be addressed, we can assist the organization in understanding the CRA’s position, responding to those concerns and considering appropriate corrective measures. Where the organization disagrees with the CRA’s conclusions, we can advise on the available avenues for challenging the decision.
Our practice
How We Can Help
Our role is not simply to respond to CRA correspondence. We help clients understand the larger legal and regulatory context of the issues being raised and determine an appropriate strategy for addressing them.
Depending on the matter, we can assist with:
- Reviewing CRA correspondence and identifying the issues involved
- Advising on requests for information and documentation
- Assisting with responses to CRA auditors and the Charities Directorate
- Reviewing charitable purposes, activities, governance and records where relevant to the CRA’s concerns
- Communicating with the CRA on behalf of the organization
- Advising directors, trustees, officers and management throughout the audit or compliance process
- Responding to compliance concerns identified by the CRA
- Negotiating and advising on compliance agreements and corrective measures
- Responding to proposed penalties, sanctions or revocation
- Preparing and pursuing objections to CRA decisions
- Dealing with assessments and reassessments
- Seeking relief from interest and penalties where appropriate
- Representing clients in tax disputes, litigation and appeals
CRA Objections and Tax Disputes
Not every disagreement with the CRA is resolved during an audit.
Where a client disagrees with an assessment, reassessment or other CRA decision, the matter may proceed to a formal objection or, where necessary, litigation or appeal.
Tax disputes are subject to procedural requirements and deadlines. Understanding the nature of the CRA decision and the available route for challenging it is therefore important from the outset.
We advise clients throughout the dispute process, from the initial review of the CRA’s position through objections, negotiations and litigation where required.
Voluntary Disclosures and Existing Compliance Concerns
Sometimes the issue is identified by the organization or taxpayer before the CRA contacts them.
An organization may discover historical reporting problems, incomplete records, incorrect filings or another matter that raises concerns about its compliance. In those circumstances, obtaining advice before approaching the CRA can help the organization understand the nature of the issue and the options that may be available.
Where appropriate, we advise clients concerning corrective action, voluntary disclosures and other approaches to addressing past non-compliance.
Advice Before You Respond
The first response to the CRA can be important.
Before providing information, documentation or a substantive response, it can be helpful to understand why the information is being requested, what legal or compliance issue may be involved, and whether the request raises concerns extending beyond the particular question being asked.
Our lawyers have extensive experience dealing with the Canada Revenue Agency, including matters involving registered charities and the CRA Charities Directorate. We help clients navigate these situations with a clear understanding of both the immediate issue and the broader implications for their organization.
If you have received correspondence from the CRA or have concerns about your organization’s compliance, contact us to discuss the matter before you respond.
CRA audits & disputes
When the CRA contacts a charity, every decision matters
Experience Matters
We are some of the most experienced charity and not-for-profit lawyers in the country.
Matters resolved
From negotiation to the highest courts, we advocate with precision and purpose.
Local understanding
Your mission, your reputation, and your resources come first.
Make an inquiry
Call us as soon as the CRA contacts you.
Please contact us through the box here and tell us about your situation.
For details about how we collect, use and protect your information, see our privacy policy.